Tech for Palestine 报告:以色列 2001 年以来 17 项操纵 Wikipedia 的行动
Israel vs. Wikipedia
Tech for Palestine 发布报告,记录了 2001 年以来 17 项亲以色列势力操纵 Wikipedia 的行动,其中 9 项仍在活跃,包括 CAMERA 秘密招募编辑和"Wikipedia 作战室"。
Campaigns to skew Wikipedia, 2001 to today
- JIDF: 2001–2015
- Israeli Government: 2007
- CAMERA: 2008
- Yesha Council: 2010
- National Library of Israel: 2012 to today , still active
- Kohelet Policy Forum: 2013 to today , still active
- NGO Monitor: 2013
- The Israel Group: 2015–2021
- Anti-Defamation League: 2021
- Wikipedia Command Center: 2023 to today , still active
- BrightMind: 2023 to today , still active
- Pro-Israel editor collusion campaign: 2024
- 4IL: 2024 to today , still active
- Yesha Council: 2024 to today , still active
- National Vision: 2024 to today , still active
- “Wikipedia Lobby Group”: 2024 to today , still active
- Jimmy Wales: 2025 to today , still active
17 campaigns since 2001. 9 are still active.
Still active Ended Read Section 3
- 01
efforts since 2001, nine still active
We document 17 pro-Israel efforts to manipulate Wikipedia since 2001. Nine are still active, from CAMERA’s secret editor recruitment to a “Wikipedia war room” and editing courses run by Zionist groups.
Read more: Section 3 - 02
ADL claims that survived scrutiny
We checked every claim in the ADL’s “Editing for Hate” report. No claim survived scrutiny. It doesn’t show a single false fact, or any antisemitic content added to Wikipedia.
Read more: Section 6 - 03
votes to keep vs. delete “Racial profiling in Israel”, an article the ADL used as evidence of collusion
The ADL picked 30 editors and called them “bad-faith”. It then listed articles these editors voted to keep, as if that proved they were working together. But the ADL left out the vote counts. We added them up. On “Racial profiling in Israel”, 22 editors voted to keep and 2 voted to delete. On “Allegations of Israeli apartheid”, it was 37 to 14. Nearly everyone who voted agreed.
Read more: Section 6.3 - 04
from pro-Israel PACs to the 23 signatories
The ADL report was used in four US government actions against Wikipedia, including a letter from 23 members of Congress. Those 23 signatories have received more than $96M from pro-Israel PACs.
Read more: Section 4 - 05
In its October 2026 follow-up report, the ADL describes the “sustained, multi-front external pressure on the platform” from Congress, federal inquiries and its own reporting.
Read more: Section 6.5 - 06
full-time ADL analysts “tracking” editors
Four groups are targeting Wikipedia editors: the Heritage Foundation, the ADL, NPOV and Builders for Tomorrow. Some editors who were doxxed have received death threats. The ADL’s CEO says he has 45 full-time analysts “tracking” editors, whom he calls “weirdos with email addresses.”
Read more: Section 4.6 - 07
Israel’s 2026 propaganda budget, up from $150M
Wikipedia feeds Google Search and every major AI chatbot. Israel’s 2026 propaganda budget is $729M, up from $150M in 2025. That includes a $46.5M contract to make AI chatbots more pro-Israel.
Read more: Section 2.2 - 08
edits by our volunteer workgroup over 8 months
The ADL blamed a coordinated editing campaign on us. Our volunteer workgroup made about 260 edits over 8 months, none of them in the core Palestine–Israel articles. That’s one fewer edit than the ADL’s own 2021 editing campaign.
Read more: Section 6.6
Read the full report online Download PDF (6.5 MB)
This report started in March 2025, when the ADL published “Editing for Hate”. The report claims Wikipedia editors colluded to add antisemitism. US politicians started using it to attack Wikipedia. We wanted to know if the report itself was part of an influence operation.
We worked on three tracks:
- Israel’s efforts to influence Wikipedia. We collected 17 publicly known campaigns from public reports, at least 9 of them still active. This is the first time they are documented in one place. (Sections 3 and 4)
- The ADL report. We went through every claim and traced each one back to the Wikipedia edits and sources it cites. None held up. (Section 6)
- The propaganda tools behind the attack. (Sections 2 and 5)
The ADL analysed Arabic Wikipedia through English translations. We went back to the original Arabic. (Section 6.4)
Links to Wikipedia are permalinks to the exact edit. Content from pro-Israel organisations and paywalled sources is linked through archive.org, so it can’t be removed or changed. (Appendix B)
Where we used AI for research, we name the tool and the prompts and publish the full conversation. AI-reconstructed links used in the report were checked by hand. (Appendices C, D and E)
Every claim in this report is footnoted, more than 500 in total.
This is a living document. We update it when corrections or new information come in. Found an error? Email contact@techforpalestine.org.
Tech for Palestine is a member-driven organization that brings together people, skills and resources. Through technology and collaboration, our members build tools and solutions that support the movement for Palestine.
These projects include: protest apps, tools for boycotting, support for Palestinian students & businesses, ethical tech alternatives, and many more.
来源:Hacker News · techforpalestine.org