跳到正文
Hacker News· crowdhailer·· 7 天前AI 评分15

The Brainmade Mark:用标识区分人类创作与 AI 生成内容

The Brainmade Mark

AI 导读

The Brainmade Mark 是一个可贴在任何作品上的标识,用于表明该作品主要由人类而非 GPT 等生成式工具创作。发起人 Tris 表示并不反对 AI,而是希望以正面方式庆祝人类创作,并认为作品约 90% 由人类完成即可,例如用 ChatGPT 找押韵、用 DALL-E 做头脑风暴可以接受,但让它代写整段诗歌或绘制大块画面则不行。

正文 · 原文

Brain mark.

When you see this logo on any artwork, whether painting, poetry, or prose, you know that it was made by a human just like you

The Brainmade mark can be attached to any work made mostly by you or your friends, not generative tools like GPT. It’s not anti-AI, it is a positive mark that celebrates homemade, human, creation. It’s not AI = bad, it’s human = good. There’s something transcendent and magical in knowing a human made the artwork I’m consuming, knowing they tried hard is part of the experience. It doesn’t have to be 100% human made (what would that even MEAN these days?), perhaps 90% human made.

I hope the following video will explain in detail for making this clear, but the tl;dr is:

  • I don’t hate AIs,
  • I love humans!

Watch my intro video here, or read on.

About

I don’t need 100% human made, I perhaps need 90% human made. Three examples may make my thinking clearer:

  • Using, say, chatgpt as a rhyming dictionary feels fine, but writing whole verses of your poem doesn’t.
  • Using DALL-E to start brainstorming with 100 generated views of birds sitting on telephone lines seems fine, but getting it to paint large sections of your artwork doesn’t.
  • Asking a text generator to give you 10 happy-sounding synonyms for despair sparks joy in me, but asking it to write your anti-trancendentalist masterpiece does not.

Using these tools to make more of the artwork you want is valid, but you’re not a creator, you’re still a consumer. I’m not sure exactly what ‘too much AI’ is, but just like your audience, I’ll know it when I see it.

I love knowing a human made the artwork I’m consuming.
There’s something there, something transcendent and magical.

I like that you tried hard, that’s part of the experience.

Downloads

Please use these however you like, I release them to the public domain under Creative Commons 0 licence.

Original, No Border

Shields.io

(see this gh issue for more details)

88x31 Buttons

About The Creator

I’m Tris, I’m a writer and producer of fast, technical videos, and audiofiction and music. My first career was as a web developer, doing production on the side for 15 years, but in 2022 I accidentally became entirely self-employed thanks to the surprising success of my YouTube channel, No Boilerplate.

Credits

Thanks so much to these lovely people who have contributed to the project:

  • Delphine Blanchard for generously sharing her marketing expertiese and developing the Brainmade brand with me
  • Logo uses two componants from the Noun Project: “Human” by JunGSa, and “seed” by Adrian Syauqi
  • Special thanks to everyone who workshopped the logo with me, especially super patron supporter Andrew Jackson. Andrew, I should be paying YOU!

This site does not use cookies

来源:Hacker News · brainmade.org